Before a Difficult Conversation, Write Down the Assumption
Prepare for a difficult conversation by naming the assumption beneath your disagreement and turning it into a neutral question that invites clarification.

Before a difficult conversation, write down the assumption you are making about the other person’s words or actions. That small pause can help you ask what you need to know instead of arguing with an interpretation that may be wrong.
An assumption is an idea you are treating as true without having checked it. It is not automatically unreasonable: people need to interpret incomplete information. The trouble starts when an interpretation quietly becomes a fact in your mind, then shapes your tone and your response.
Separate what happened from what you inferred
Begin with the observable event. Write what someone said or did as plainly as you can, without adding a motive. Then write the meaning you attached to it. Keeping those notes separate makes the assumption easier to see.
For instance, “The project update arrived after the meeting” describes an event. “They waited because they do not respect my time” adds an explanation. The explanation might be accurate, but the event alone does not establish it.
Use a simple two-column note if that helps:
- What I could have recorded: the words, action, timing or decision.
- What I think it means: the motive, priority or intention I am inferring.
Keep the first column narrow. “They always ignore me” is not a direct observation; it combines a broad judgement with an assumption. If you cannot point to a particular moment, choose a concrete instance before preparing the conversation.
Write one assumption, not a case against someone
Now complete this sentence privately: “I am assuming that…” Choose the belief that most affects how you are approaching the disagreement. It might concern what the other person intended, what they understood, or what they value.
Do not turn the note into a list of every past grievance. A long record encourages you to argue for a verdict rather than ask about the uncertainty in front of you. One assumption gives the conversation a manageable starting point.
Say you are preparing to speak with a colleague who changed a shared document without discussing it. You could write, “I am assuming that they thought my input was not worth waiting for.” That sentence identifies your interpretation; it does not establish their motive or excuse the change.
Make the wording specific enough to examine. “They do not care” is so broad that almost any action could seem to support it. “They believed the deadline mattered more than checking the change with me” names a particular possible explanation that the other person can clarify.
Turn the assumption into a neutral question
Use the note to ask about the missing information, not to smuggle in an accusation. A neutral question leaves room for an answer you did not predict.
In the document example, “Why did you disregard my input?” already treats disregard as fact. A more open question is: “What led you to make the change before we had discussed it?” If the assumption is about priorities, you could ask, “How were you weighing the deadline against getting my input?”
Before speaking, check that your question does not contain a hidden conclusion. Words such as “ignored”, “deliberately” and “obviously” can present an inference as settled. Replace them with a description of the action, then ask what you do not yet know.
Think of the written assumption as a pencil mark on a map, not the destination. It helps you identify where to ask for directions; it does not tell you what the other person will say.
Use the answer to revise your interpretation
Ask the question, then give the other person room to answer. Listen for information that bears on the assumption: what they noticed, what they intended, and what constraints shaped the decision. You do not have to agree with their account to understand it.
In the colleague example, they might say they made the change because a required update had arrived and they believed there was no time to wait. That answer would not settle whether the choice was reasonable. It would, however, distinguish a deadline judgement from the assumption that your input had no value.
If their answer is unclear, ask a narrower follow-up about the point you still do not understand. If it confirms part of your concern, shift to the actual issue: what effect the decision had and what you would like handled differently next time. The aim is not to force your assumption to disappear; it is to avoid treating it as proven before the conversation begins.
What should you ask yourself before you speak?
How do I know this is an assumption?
Look for a claim about motive, intention or belief that you cannot directly observe. If your note describes what someone must have meant rather than what they said or did, it is an interpretation to check.
What if there are several possible explanations?
Write down the explanation you are most tempted to treat as certain, then leave room for alternatives. You do not need to invent a favourable motive; you only need to recognise that you have not yet established one.
What if I still feel angry?
Anger can point to a concern, but it does not answer the question of what the other person intended. Keep your question focused on the event and the missing information, and pause the discussion if you cannot speak without turning it into a charge.
Keep the preparation brief and useful
A useful note can fit in three lines: the observable event, the assumption you are making, and the neutral question you want to ask. Read it once before the conversation. If the question still sounds like an accusation, rewrite it in language the other person could answer without first accepting your interpretation.
Before a difficult conversation, writing down the assumption is not a way to soften every disagreement or concede your point. It is a way to make your reasoning visible to yourself, so you can test the uncertain part and discuss the part that remains.


